Close Menu

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    3TREES Sees Asia-Pacific Cooperation as a Win-Win Business Boost

    November 21, 2026

    Guinea ends mpox outbreak more than two years after first case

    November 21, 2026

    WFP warns funding gaps will leave millions hungry in 2027

    November 21, 2026
    GCC DigestGCC Digest
    • Automotive
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Health
    • Lifestyle
    • Luxury
    • News
    • Sports
    • Technology
    • Travel
    GCC DigestGCC Digest
    Home » Revival of the Sword of the Prophet Zulfiqar Amid Unexpected Reactions
    Featured News

    Revival of the Sword of the Prophet Zulfiqar Amid Unexpected Reactions

    February 18, 2025
    Facebook WhatsApp Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Telegram Tumblr Email Reddit VKontakte

    The National’s Response Sparks Discussion on the Historical Symbolism

    Newszy: Bern, Switzerland – Between January 28 and February 5, 2025, two press releases were published regarding discovering a unique ancient blade, attributed to the Sword of the Prophet Muhammad, Zulfiqar. This conclusion was based on extensive research conducted by a team of renowned scientists and specialized experts.

    However, on February 6, 2025, The National published an article casting doubt on the research, followed by modifications on February 7. Despite attempts to address inaccuracies directly with the authors and management, no response was received, prompting the release of key points from these communications.

    Concerns Raised About The National’s Article

    In a letter addressed to the authors William Mullally and Faisal Al Zaabi, their article raised concerns about the selective use of expert opinions. The piece relied on only two experts, and as stated in the letter:

    “Did each of them read the entire 100-page research document that you undoubtedly received earlier? I’m sure they have not. And if they have, then it is doubtful that even a mid-level professional would allow themselves to operate so selectively and biasedly on just one minor aspect of the research results.”

    Furthermore, The National’s article referenced a statement by Ahmed Ali, a visiting professor from the University of Sharjah, claiming:

    “Given that early Islamic swords typically lacked elaborate inscriptions—especially those relating to later historical figures—this strongly suggests that the sword in question was either created later or was intended for symbolic rather than martial purposes.”

    The letter refutes this claim, pointing out that a full chapter of the research document is dedicated to proving the sword’s combat use, making this critique baseless. The letter further questioned:

    “What ‘later historical figures’ is Mr. Ali referring to? What ‘symbolic, not combat purposes’ is suggested when our research demonstrates irrefutable evidence of the sword’s martial use?”

    Additionally, the lack of comparative analysis with the nine known swords attributed to the Prophet Muhammad—eight in Turkey and one in Egypt—was highlighted as a major oversight in The National’s assessment.

    Scientific Basis of the Research

    A second letter, sent on February 7, 2025, further addressed the flawed approach in the article, emphasizing that a comprehensive artifact examination must be based on four fundamental pillars: art historical research, material investigations, appraisal, and legal studies.

    It was emphasized that:

    “A professional critic—whether a scientist, journalist, or sociologist—must obtain objective arguments from multiple authoritative experts across all four disciplines before making a definitive statement. However, your article was based on the opinions of just two individuals, with conclusions seemingly drawn within a couple of days of ‘analytical study’—a completely inadequate timeframe for such a complex historical analysis.”

    Furthermore, the study of the sword began in 2006 and continues today, involving a multi-national, multi-confessional team of researchers. Inscriptions on the blade, including the names of the Prophet Muhammad’s family and repeated mentions of Ali, are powerful evidence of the sword’s historical significance.

    The letter also addressed a fundamental misconception in The National’s article regarding artifact authentication, explaining that:

    “Absolute proof of authenticity for any historical artifact would require a direct eyewitness to its creation, which is impossible for objects from ancient history. Instead, scholarly communities accept the ‘most proven version’ based on accumulated expert research—just as museums label items as ‘Napoleon’s sword’ or ‘Aivazovsky’s painting’ based on extensive authentication processes. By these established standards, the status of our sword as ‘Zulfiqar’ is the strongest analytically substantiated conclusion available.”

    Call for a Scholarly Approach

    The response from Muslim readers and historical scholars has been overwhelmingly supportive, with many expressing appreciation for the scientific findings.

    Given the significance of this discovery, we encourage a balanced, scholarly discussion and welcome further objective, evidence-based evaluation of our findings.

    As the world reflects on this remarkable historical revelation, we extend our respects to the Muslim community at the beginning of the Holy Month of Ramadan.

    Contact:

    1. Tamoikin, Professor, Ph.D.
      (Expert in Art, Appraisal, and Law)

    Email: miketamoikin@yahoo.com

    Related Posts

    Tüyap highlights MENA sourcing opportunities at the carpet expo in Istanbul

    November 17, 2026

    Narwal Unveils Flow 2: Revolutionary FlowWash Mopping System with VLM OmniVision Intelligence

    November 14, 2026

    Clemta Expands Partner API to Power End-to-End U.S. Business Services

    November 12, 2026

    OMEGA Expands Beyond CGI to Form Full-Service Property Development Marketing Agency

    November 4, 2026

    Dun & Bradstreet SAME Brings D&B’s Global AI Capabilities to Local Markets

    October 29, 2026

    Mulk Technology Partners with OnClarity (USA) to Launch Integrated AI Health Tech Across India, Africa and the UAE

    October 24, 2026
    News Bulletin

    Guinea ends mpox outbreak more than two years after first case

    November 21, 2026

    Guinea has officially ended its mpox outbreak, more than two years after the country confirmed its first case of the disease. Health Minister Khaite Sall announced the decision on Thursday, November 19, in an official statement read on national television.

    WFP warns funding gaps will leave millions hungry in 2027

    November 21, 2026

    Millions more people will go hungry next year as funding shortfalls continue, the World Food Programme (WFP) warned as it released its Global Outlook for 2027 in Geneva. The UN agency said it will require $12.1 billion to assist 91

    Chip boom lifts South Korea into $1 trillion export club

    November 21, 2026

    South Korea has become the fourth country in the world to export more than $1 trillion worth of goods in a single year, joining the United States, China and Germany. The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Resources said cumulative exports

    PM Modi meets Prince and Princess of Wales for climate talks

    November 21, 2026

    The economic and strategic relationship between New Delhi and London is accelerating as both governments move to modernize their historic bilateral frameworks. Official state updates confirm that PM Modi meets Prince and Princess of Wales to advance the comprehensive strategic

    © 2026 GCC Digest | All Rights Reserved
    • Home
    • Contact Us

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.